top of page

REFERENCES:

2013b. Netflix's Ted Sarandos talks Arrested Development, 4K and reviving old shows [Online]. Stuff.tv. Available: http://www.stuff.tv/news/apps-and-games/news-nugget/netflixs-ted-sarandos-talks-arrested-development-4k-and-reviving-old [Accessed 1st May, 2013].

2013c. Spotify Information [Online]. Available: http://press.spotify.com/au/information/ [Accessed 1st May, 2012].

AAKER, D. A. & MCLOUGHLIN, D. 2010. Strategic market management, John Wiley & Sons Canada, Limited.

BUSARI, S. 2011. Spotify founder: I'm not music industry's savior [Online]. CNN. Available: http://edition.cnn.com/2011/12/08/tech/web/spotify-daniel-ek [Accessed 1st May, 2013].

CARLSON, N. 2013. Spotify Plans To Take On Netflix And HBO With Streaming Video Service [Online]. Business Insider. Available: http://au.businessinsider.com/spotify-plans-to-take-on-netflix-and-hbo-with-streaming-video-service-2013-3 [Accessed 26th March, 2013].

ELDON, E. 2012. Spotify Is Having A Good 2012: Revenues Could Reach $500M As It Expands The Digital Music Market [Online]. TechCrunch. Available: http://techcrunch.com/2012/11/10/spotify-is-having-a-good-2012-revenues-could-reach-500m-as-it-expands-the-digital-music-market/ [Accessed 28th, May 2013].

KNOPPER, S. 2009. Appetite for Self-Destruction: The Spectacular Crash of the Record Industry in the Digital Age, New York, US, Free Press.

LINDVALL, H. 2008. Behind the music at Musexpo: Can we fix a 'broken' industry? The Guardian, 30th October

​LUCKERSON, V. 2013. Revenue Up, Piracy Down: Has the Music Industry Finally Turned a Corner? [Online]. Time. Available: http://business.time.com/2013/02/28/revenue-up-piracy-down-has-the-music-industry-finally-turned-a-corner/ [Accessed 1st May, 2013].

LUERSSEN, J. D. 2008. Gene Simmons Blames Radiohead, NIN for Dead Music Biz [Online]. Spinner.com. Available: http://www.spinner.com/2008/06/19/gene-simmons-blames-radiohead-nin-fans-for-dead-music-biz/ [Accessed 2nd May, 2013].

NPD GROUP, 2013. Music FIle Sharing Declined Significantly in 2012 [Online]. Port Washington, NY The NPD Group. Available: https://www.npd.com/wps/portal/npd/us/news/press-releases/the-npd-group-music-file-sharing-declined-significantly-in-2012/ [Accessed 2nd May, 2013].

PFANNER, E. 2013. Music Industry Sales Rise, and Digital Revenue Gets the Credit. The New York Times, p.B3.

 

ROBERTSON, M. 2011. Why Spotify can never be profitable: The secret demands of record labels [Online]. Gigaom. Available: http://gigaom.com/2011/12/11/why-spotify-can-never-be-profitable-the-secret-demands-of-record-labels/ [Accessed 20th May, 2013].

SISARIO, B. 2012. Pandora and Spotify Rake In the Money and Then Send It Off in Royalties [Online]. The New York Times. Available: http://mediadecoder.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/08/24/pandora-and-spotify-rake-in-the-money-and-then-send-it-off-in-royalties/ [Accessed 20th May, 2012].

WALTERS, H. 2008. The music industry in freefall. Or: The lesser-noted point about Radiohead [Online]. New York City, US: Bloomberg L.P. Available: http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2008-01-06/the-music-industry-in-freefall-dot-or-the-lesser-noted-point-about-radiohead January].

CASE STUDY: SPOTIFY

As the first media business to experience digitalisation, the recording industry unwittingly set a precedent for the financially destructive power of The Digital Revolution. There are undeniable parallels to be drawn between the effects upon both the recording and television mediums at the hand of this revolution. In order to garner a better understanding of the possible trajectory of the television industry post-digitalisation, one should first examine the music industry during its period of ‘freefall’ (Walters, 2008). From the advent of pioneering file-sharing service Napster in 1999, the recording industry suffered twelve straight years of decreasing profits, largely due to the exponential rise in peer-to-peer (P2P) file sharing. 2012 marked a small, albeit symbolic change, with the industry posting a revenue increase of 0.3 percent (Luckerson, 2013). As of last year, global recorded music revenues stood at $16.5 billion, almost half the $38b the industry took in during its peak in the pre-digital 1990’s (PFANNER, 2013).

During this seemingly endless profit ‘freefall’, many theorists, broadsheet journalists and even iconic frontmen pejoratively declared the music business ‘crashed’ (Knopper, 2009) ‘dead’ (Luerssen, 2008) and ‘broken’ (Lindvall, 2008).  Although last year's increase does not undo more than a decade of declining profits, new research suggests commercial streaming services like Spotify helped engender this turnaround (2013b). However Spotify founder and CEO Daniel Ek insists he’s  not the saviour of the recording industry (Busari, 2011), despite findings from a recent study by international research group NPD indicating a correlation between the rise of streaming services and the decline in music piracy (NPD GROUP, 2013). According to this study the number of consumers using P2P file sharing services declined by 17 percent in 2012, with the worldwide volume of illegally downloaded music files declining by 26 percent. More tellingly, the study also found nearly half of P2P file sharing consumers cited their use of legal music streaming services as the primary reason for stopping, or reducing their sharing activity. These statistics help validate claims streaming services are now an important fixture in music consumption habits.

Since its inception in Sweden 2006 Spotify has launched in more than 28 countries. The world’s leading music streaming service, it has over 24 million active users, more than six million of whom pay monthly subscriptions (2013c). In their in-depth marketing and management study David A. Aaker and Damien McLoughlin state it was Spotify’s ability to anticipate and address the “nebulous pattern of change” (Aaker and Mcloughlin, 2010) in the music industry which prevented the company from liquidation. While early market competitors Ruckus and SpiralFrog were forced to shut down operations during the global economic downturn of 2008, Spotify grew and ‘changed rapidly’ (Aaker and Mcloughlin, 2010) in an ‘unforgiving’ climate (Aaker and Mcloughlin, 2010). If recent speculation can be believed, the company has no plans to rest on its laurels.  According to its ‘sources’ Business Insider claims the streaming giant plans to directly challenge Netflix by also adding a video streaming service, which will reportedly include its own original content (CARLSON, 2013).

While the history of Spotify in many ways reads like a dot com success story, the company’s financial situation is far from perfect. The costs of acquiring the rights to stream the music in its library are extraordinary. Its current licensing agreement requires Spotify pay either $200M, or around 75 per cent of total revenue (whichever is higher) annually to record labels (SISARIO, 2012). This agreement explains why, in its five year history, the company is yet to post profits. Digital music entrepreneur Michael Robertson argues such monopolistic licensing agreements mean Spotify and other music on-demand services in their current form can never be profitable (ROBERTSON, 2011). Despite this Spotify’s aggressive international expansion in recent years has also rapidly increased the company’s revenue. According to TechCrunch, the company made as much as $500M in 2012 up from $248M the previous year (ELDON, 2012). However, it must be noted this figure has not been confirmed by Spotify, and does not include the cost of the company’s aforementioned international expansion.

While questions of the recording industry’s sustainability often dominate discussions around piracy, it’s important to consider the positive effects file sharing has had on the wider music industry. In their accurate 2006 analysis of the future of the music industry David Kusek and Gerd Leonhard predict the forthcoming ubiquity of music. Dating only months after the creation of BitTorrent file sharing, their study argues such technologies are, contrary to popular perception, bolstering not killing the music industry in ways unimaginable pre-MP3. The study debunks the myth that the industry is dying, arguing instead more music has been consumed in the five years previous to the book’s publication than ever before, despite rapidly declining album sales (Kusek and Leonhard, 2005).


Kusek and Leonhard also argue the rise convergent media has enabled many artist to record high-quality content, using homemade studios and distribute their art online. According to the authors this business model, inconceivable less than a decade ago for many reason including prohibitive costs, has strengthened the industry.
Fast forward seven years and the same is true, at least in part, for the television industry. As the CEO of major North American TV network CBS says, more people are watching programming than ever before, they’re just consuming it differently (Steel, 2012); ‘differently’, of course, meaning streaming it online. A recent study by independent market research group eMarketer found the number of US television viewers consuming the medium online continues to rise dramatically, with an expected annualized growth rate of almost seven percent year-on-year to 2017 (2013a). Citing the success of Netflix the study argues US consumers are approaching a tipping point, where record numbers are considering replacing their conventional cable/satellite subscriptions with an on-demand streaming subscription, or as the industry aptly refers to it “cutting the cord”.

In the future of the industry, as Kusek and Leonhard predict, consumers would simply pay a monthly fee, much like they do with their amenities, to consume content  wherever and whenever they wanted. The unquestionable rise and increasing ubiquity of on-demand services are proving the pair correct.

bottom of page